Showing posts with label Identity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Identity. Show all posts

Thursday, April 7, 2016

Dear Stupid People,

I know I shouldn't let other people's idiocy bother me so much, but there comes a point where I can no longer just watch another human being say really, really, really, REALLY moronic things without keeping my mouth shut and saying something about it.


This thing about people making up brand new “gender identities” that are unconnected to anything in reality has reached epic proportions of dumb.


Seriously.


Have you heard about this shit?


From what I can tell, it all started with people who were honestly suffering trying to get together to help each other get through things, and to help those of us lucky to not have their problems understand what they were going through. Unfortunately, what it has evolved into is a clown-show. Its now a complete joke. Its an echo-chamber where people whose only real shared problem could be charitably described – and recognized as such by anyone with a working brain – as “social ineptitude.”


These sad people sit in on discussions of equal rights for homosexuals and transgendered people, learning the lingo and the common arguments and that that carefully garnered intel and turn it to their own purposes. They quote famous human rights activists way, way out of context to add that elusive whiff of legitimacy to a situation that couldn't be less legitimate if its parents hadn't been married when it was born. They act as if their “fight for equality” was morally and factually equal to the fight to end racism, transphobia, homophobia, class discrimination, or sexism. They worm their way into discussions of actual, real issues and then cleverly turn statements that were originally designed to protect true victims who are at risk of losing their jobs and lives to their own benefit.


I'm talking about the so-called “otherkin” and “otakukin.”


In case you're unaware, otherkin and otakukin are people who “identify” as animals or anime characters, respectively.


No, really. They do that.


No, I'm not joking. I promise, I'm not joking. This is actually a thing.


They really do “identify” as animals and anime characters.


Now, I'm a pretty open-minded guy. My basic philosophy is that you can do, say, or believe what you want as long as what you are doing, saying, and believing doesn't hurt anyone else and as long as you aren't shoving your actions, statements, and beliefs in other people's faces when they don't want you to do so. But this shit is just too stupid for me to let go.


According to these people, the lack of widespread acceptance of “otherkin” and “otakukin” is contributing to an environment of mass oppression. Mass oppression? Really? So these people are losing their jobs and being beaten up and murdered and raped because they think they're a chinchilla trapped in a human body? Because they think they are actually the human incarnation of Shinji Ikari? No? None of that is actually happening? No one's actually being killed or beaten or forced out of their jobs? Then what, I ask, is actually going on that could possibly qualify as “mass oppression?”


What's that you say? People are listening to these people say that they are actually animals or anime characters and are laughing at them instead of just accepting it? People are being mean on the internet and not just believing these people out of hand? That's your so-called “mass oppression?”


Are you kidding me, here?


In addition to these weirdos, a new form of personal delusion has popped up onto the landscape. You've all no doubt heard of transgender, but have you heard of transabled? How about transethnic?


No?


Well, if you've got a few hours free and a lot of booze handy, try googling the term “transabled oppression” or “transethnic oppression” and then sit back and prepare to be entertained.


Transabled people are – apparently – disabled people who were unfortunate enough to be born in perfectly functional bodies. They “identity” as being blind, deaf, paraplegic, quadriplegic, and so on despite not having been any of those things a day in their lives. They talk a lot about how hard it is to go through life in a perfectly healthy body.


Transethnic people, on the other hand, are basically people who “identify” as being part of a different ethnicity. In the 90s we called people like that “weeaboos,” except these jokers take it up to 11. The weeaboos just acted like they weren't white or Asian or whatever. These people really do believe they are truly of another ethnicity.


Quick digression: I thought that “transethnicity” was a sick joke until a friend sent me a link to a blog by a white man who “identifies” as a black woman. He apparently claims that he is “oppressed” by other black women who have the gall to actually question his self-proclaimed “identity”.


And then there's the “demi-sexuals.” Apparently, these are people who are sexually attracted to people they are in love with. Yeah, really. They claim that this is a real sexual orientation and that they are being oppressed. How are they being oppressed? I have no idea.


I find the very idea of these people offensive. I feel that they are mocking the very real pain and the very real struggle of disabled people and ethnic minorities to find an equal place in our society. And the greedy appropriation of the “trans experience” just so they can claim to be marginalized is disgusting to me. What these people claim to “suffer” is nothing compared to what actual trans people go through on a daily basis. They are not going to be denied a job, they are not going to be denied housing, they are not going to be forced to be who they aren't, they are not going to be subject to violence because they are “transfat” or “transblind” or “transasian” of whatever.


“Trans” is short for “transitioning.” These people aren't transitioning. They're appropriating.


These yahoos have even come up with a special term for those of us who have too much common sense and too much compassion for the struggle of real transgender people to buy into their nonsense. They call us “singlets.” Apparently, all of us who walk around refusing to buy into their nonsense enjoy “cisprivilege.” People who are actually disabled apparently enjoy “cisability privilege”, while actually people of color enjoy “cisethnic privilege.”


Well isn't that special.


This might be the height of arrogant bullshit. These people just need to stop. Right now. Just stop. If they had any real idea how hard it was to live with a disability, to be denied employment or housing because of their gender identity, to be treated as less than human because of their skin color, would they really be clamoring to be a part of it?


As a straight white man who “identifies” as the gender he was born into I can't speak for those groups, but I can tell you that living with a disability is hard! I'm in pain pretty much 24-7-365. I have vertigo spells of various intensity every ten or twelve minutes, some of which last just moments, while others last minutes. I have trouble walking, tire easily, and sometimes can't remember what I want to remember. And I got off lucky! This is not something that should be reduced to a punchline so that someone can pretend that they are oppressed.


As for the so-called “demi-sexuals”, you assholes need to stop blogging about coming out as demi-sexual to your parents as if it was such a fucking hardship. Do you really believe that, in a heteronormative world, that your mom and dad are going to have a hissy fit because you enjoy the most normal, vanilla form of sexual attraction on the planet? Really? You're not oppressed, you're vanilla. I don't remember ever seeing a news article about a “demi-sexual” who was murdered for being “demi,” or thrown out of their apartment, or fired from their job.


And finally, let me direct my eye to you people who claim to be “transfat”. Shut. The. Fuck. Up. I don't care if you weigh a thousand tons on the inside, on the outside you're still just a skinny asshole. You still get to walk into any clothing store you want and buy your clothes with ease. You can go into a restaurant to eat without having people snicker over your size and how much you're eating. You can go to a grocery store without people staring at what's in your cart and making jokes. When you go to a doctor, you don't have him constantly warning you of the heart attack you're going to have at any moment even if everything else about you is healthy and normal.


Shut. The. Fuck. Up.


I wish these people were a put on. I really do. But the more I read about these idiots, the more I realize that they are deadly serious. It disgusts me to a point that its impossible for me to actually describe. Being marginalized because of a disability or your sexuality or your ethnicity is horrible and affects your life in real and painful ways.


Again, I can't speak for people of color or the transgedered, but I can tell you that “disabled” is not just a label you wear for shits and giggles. Its something you struggle with from the moment you open your eyes in the morning until the moment you fall asleep at night. It means that you often die earlier from the stress of just living than you might if you were healthy. This isn't some cutesy game where you pretend to be suffering, claiming to be oppressed and engaging in fake outrage over how the rest of the world refuses to accept you.


Stop. Just stop.

Monday, January 5, 2015

I Did Check My Privilege... and You're Still Wrong!

I've spoken about this before, but I think its time to bring it up again.  The entire concept of privilege, as the word is used by the Social Justice Warriors, is bothersome, over-convenient, and, to be honest, a cop-out.


White privilege.  Male privilege.  Hetero-privilege.  The list just gets longer by the day.


These supposedly privileged groups of people are believed to have certain inherent advantages based on their ethnicity, their gender, their sexual orientation, and so on.  And because they supposedly all enjoy these bonuses in life, they have no right to hold opinions, or to express those opinions, when it comes to the issue-du-jour.


The truth is, the concept of privilege is just being used to stop meaningful discussion before it begins by shaming the so-called "privileged" person into silence.  The phrase "check your privilege" is an easy way to say, "I know more than you do, so shut the fuck up already."  Its a cheap attempt to make someone feel guilty about things they have no control over.


Not to mention, its utterly stupid.



Should women not have opinions on things that only affect men?  If I ever encounter a woman commenting on the Selective Service, or testicular cancer, or male disposability, should I tell her to "check her privilege" because, as a woman, she enjoys "female privilege" and thus isn't allowed to voice an opinion on these issues?


Seriously, guys... if we keep this sort of exclusionary bullshit up, we're never going to truly overcome racism and sexism.  The discussions about these problems have to include everyone's opinions, everyone's views.  
Everyone's views.  Even the views of people we disagree with.  If they don't include everyone, then they aren't actually discussions.  They're lectures.  And lectures don't convince people who feel they are being attacked for something they do not and cannot control.  Like the fact that they are men.  Or are white.


I think the worst part of the entire idea of privilege as its used by the Social Justice Warriors is that it creates preconceived opinions about people you really do not know.  Seriously, saying that I (for example) benefit from "white male privilege" in response to something that I say assumes that I (as the white male in question) have it easier than you do; that I don't have to struggle just as hard (if not harder) than you do just to keep a roof over my head and food on the table.


Perhaps before accusing me of "white male privilege" you should check your own prejudices and acknowledge that you do not know me well enough to make those sorts of judgments.  Have you ever considered the fact that I might be unemployed and on the edge of poverty?  Have you considered that I might be blind, or deaf, or in a wheelchair, and thus suffer from some limiting disability?  Have you considered that I might have terminal cancer and am slowly dying?  Maybe I've got crushing depression and constantly battle suicidal thoughts all day.


Just because I have a penis and my skin is a pale shade of peach does not automatically mean my life is easy.  It doesn't mean that at all.


You remember that old joke about what assuming things makes out of you and me, right?


The concept of "privilege" as the Social Justice Warriors use it puts people in individual boxes that are carefully labeled, and it insists we see these people, all of whom are just as multi-faceted as you are, and all of whom have lives as complex as you do, as nothing more than the labels attached to the boxes.  Someone needs to explain to me how seeing people as labels is a desirable thing.


Sorry, guys, but life doesn't work that way.  People are not labels.  People are way too complicated for that.  Sure, I might have some shared experiences with other white men, but I'm sure that if you compared me to any other randomly selected white guy you'd find plenty about our lives that was utterly different.  Different personalities, different likes and dislikes, different incomes, different cultural background, differences in intelligence and education, different life struggles, differences in political opinion.


Different advantages.  Different disadvantages.


Some people have told me that privilege exists because "all else being equal," certain people are inherently more privileged than other people.  But this is nonsense.  When, I ask you, are any two random people exactly the same except for one specific characteristic?  When?  When the hell does that ever happen in the real world?  This argument fails spectacularly because the way someone is treated depends on the situation.  In some cases, yes, being a white male might work to my advantage, but it could just as easily be a liability in other cases.


And the same goes for any other ethnicity-gender combination.



We can and should empathize with others.  I have no idea what its like to live as a black man or a gay woman.  But here's the thing:  I have no idea what its like to live as the randomly selected white guy I used in one of my previous examples, either.  And here's something else:  they have no fucking clue how it is to live as me.


Because no one on the face of the Earth is living a life identical to mine.  No one.


So anyway... I guess what I am trying to say here is that I think the world would be a better place if we stopped making arrogant assumptions about other people based on superficial classifications like skin color or what sort of genitalia they're carrying around.  Every individual faces different problems in their life, and no one else is really able to understand what they are going through completely.


Your background differs from mine.  Hell, your background differs from that of your siblings and your parents and your children.  And because of this, you should keep an open mind and recognize that communication is a two-way street.

Saturday, December 13, 2014

A Question of Privilege

Just recently, a fight broke out over on my friend Andy Beals page.  I have to apologize to him about that, because part of it was my fault and I certainly didn't mean to start a war on his page.  Anyway, during a digression regarding shaming tactics and how they were used by people to defend their positions of privilege rather than deal with criticism of that privilege, I mentioned that women themselves were not bereft of privilege, and that implying that only men (specifically white men) were privileged was to directly state a falsehood.  (That is, the idea was a great big lie.)

In response, a rather obstinate and fallacy-loving woman named Judith Merriam stepped in and made the following comment:


"I'm going to point and laugh now about a man arguing that feminists have the "entrenched privilege" in this society."


I find it interesting to note that, as I have already pointed out is common with fringe feminist extremists like Ms. Merriam, she is conflating "woman" with "feminist", and is assuming that any criticism of "feminism" is actually a criticism of "women."  That she cannot get her head around the truth (that "feminism" and "women" are two separate concepts entirely, and that criticism of one is not criticism of the other) shows you just about where this argument headed shortly thereafter.


In any case, her denial that such a thing as female privilege even exists prompts me to supply the following list.  This list is not original to me.  It was originally written by activist Karen Straughan, a woman who is the first person I point to whenever someone says that "MRAs" are all just a bunch of angry men who hate women.


Straughan has this to say about the concept of social privilege:

"It's a contest these days, and to hear people talk, everyone's vying for the prized spot at the very, very, very bottom.  Discussions of race, class, sexuality, gender and gender identity, disability, economic status, education level, all seem to devolve into a bizarre exercise in "one-downmanship" where everyone clamors that they are a more victimy victim than anyone else.
But some things really are black and white -- at least they seem so.  When considering things like male/female gender privilege, you need only consider the bilateral -- that is, how does one play out in relation to the other?  That is, what privileges do men enjoy solely due to their gender that women of similar economic class, education level, race, able-bodiedness, sexual orientation, etc. etc. do not?
And conversely -- and contrary to what many feminists believe -- what privileges do women enjoy that men do not, all things being equal?  I was asked by a feminist to name one example of so-called "female privilege".  Rather than name one, I named over seventy of them."


This is her Female Privilege Checklist.  Straughan asks, "Women are requested to consider whether they can answer "yes" to these questions."


  1. Are people likely to assume I am a warm and empathetic person, just because of my gender?
  2. Are people likely to assist me when I must perform a physically arduous task, just because of my gender?
  3. If my car breaks down or I am otherwise in distress, are people more likely to stop and help me, just because of my gender?
  4. If I am being physically assaulted, no matter the gender of my assailant, it is more likely that passersby will intervene?
  5. Are people are likely to assume I am a competent parent, unless and until I prove otherwise?
  6. Are people are more likely to respect my right to be offended by inappropriate or impolite behavior?
  7. If I act in a cruel or verbally abusive manner to members of the opposite gender, I am likely to have people assume I am automatically in the right?
  8. If I yell or otherwise make an aggressive display, are people less likely to believe I am going to hurt them physically?
  9. Are dress codes in the workplace and in leisure contexts more likely to allow me to choose clothing that emphasize my most attractive features and minimize those I am unhappy with?
  10. Am I allowed by society to wear cosmetics to make myself more attractive without anyone questioning my sexual orientation?
  11. Am I given a large social leeway in the kinds of hairstyles I can choose that will flatter my facial features?
  12. If I work in a profession that is dominated by the opposite gender, are people likely to see it as "heroic", or a sign of social progress, rather than that I am deficient or less capable of other members of my gender in some way?
  13. If I am sexually harassed in the workplace and lodge a complaint, am I more likely to be believed than a person of the opposite gender making the same complaint would be?
  14. If I making crude or sexually explicit jokes at the workplace, am I less likely to cause coworkers of the opposite gender to complain about sexual harassment to my supervisor than I would were I a member of the opposite gender?
  15. If I show weakness in public, is the first response most people have to me consolation and assistance, rather than criticizing me for weakness, ignoring me, or dismissing me as pathetic?
  16. Am I expected to not make the "first move" when meeting members of the opposite sex for the purposes of dating?  Are members of the opposite gender expected to make the "first move?"  Therefore, is it less likely I will be sexually rejected by those I come into close contact with in a dating context?
  17. Am I expected to not spend a significant portion of my yearly income on a token that accompanies a marriage proposal?
  18. Am I less likely to be expected to spend a significant amount of money on gifts, tokens, and activities during courtship and dating?
  19. If I am having dinner with a member of the opposite gender in a dating context, and I do not reach for the check, are people unlikely to assume I am cheap.
  20. If I am having dinner with a member of the opposite gender in a non-dating context, and I do not reach for the check, are people still unlikely to assume I am cheap?
  21. If I am heterosexual and I refuse sexual intercourse with a person of the opposite gender, especially if that person is considered greatly attractive, will neither my sexual orientation nor my gender identity be called into question?
  22. If I am homosexual, are sexual acts between my partner and myself more likely to be seen as acceptable by heterosexuals than if I and my partner were members of the opposite gender?
  23. Am I much more likely to get away with using gender-derived insults (cocksucker, cunt, dickhead, prick, pussy, twat, and so on) without having someone call me out for using "sexist" terminology than they would were I a member of the opposite gender?
  24. If I earn less than my partner, am I considered a failure by society?
  25. If I earn nothing at all and my partner supports me completely, am I considered a failure by society?
  26. If I am unemployed and my partner is supporting me, are people other than my partner unlikely to pressure me because I am "not trying hard enough" to find employment?
  27. If I choose to discontinue, temporarily leave, or reduce my participation in a high-status career in order to spend more time at home caring for my children, are people likely to consider it a "noble sacrifice" rather than a waste of my talents?
  28. If I make the choice to be a stay-at-home parent and take care of my children while my partner is supporting me, are people other than my partner unlikely to pressure me to "get a real job"?  Am I unlikely to be seen as a deadbeat, unskilled, or shirking my responsibility to my family?
  29. If I earn less than my partner, are people unlikely to expect me to nevertheless contribute equally to our living expenses?
  30. If I am skilled in activities or hobbies that are commonly attributed to the opposite gender (kickboxing, operating power tools, shingling a roof, knitting, scrap-booking, floral arranging, and so on) are other people likely to see me as admirable rather than that I am weak, strange, or homosexual?
  31. If I am completing a task along with a member of the opposite gender, will they be expected to take on the greater physical burden (such as carrying and moving heavy objects)?
  32. If I am injured and start crying, are other people unlikely to tell me to "suck it up?"
  33. If an employer claims to have "non-sexist" hiring policies, can I assume this to mean that members of my gender will be more likely to be hired?
  34. If I choose a career in early childhood or elementary level education, or volunteer to work with children, are people unlikely to wonder if I am choosing such a career because I am secretly a pedophile who is looking to get close to potential victims?
  35. If I choose a career in early childhood or elementary level education, or volunteer to work with children, will the parents of these children trust me implicitly, despite the fact that members of my gender are more likely to use positions of authority over children as a means to facilitate the sexual abuse of those children?
  36. If I commit a crime against children, are people more likely to want to believe that I have been falsely accused or "failed by the system" or was somehow "driven to it" by factors outside of my control, even before the details of the crime are revealed because members of my gender "just don't do stuff like that?"  Is it unlikely that people will automatically attribute my actions to unprovoked aggression or hold me entirely responsible for them?
  37. If I am a victim of domestic violence, are there many services in my community that are specifically geared toward people of my gender and in my situation?  Am I unlikely to be denied these services because of my gender?
  38. If report my partner to the authorities for physically abusing me, will I likely be believed by the authorities, whether I possess signs of physical injury or not?
  39. If I physically abuse my partner, will people -- including the authorities and victim's services workers -- be likely to assume that I only did it out of self-defense, even if I tell them that I instigated the violence and that my partner is pacifistic and non-violent?
  40. If I physically abuse my partner, will people -- including the authorities and victim's services workers -- assume that my partner did something to provoke me (like cheating on me, yelling at me, or otherwise causing me to temporarily lose control)?
  41. If I physically abuse my partner and they reciprocate, is my partner far more likely to be the one arrested, even if the partner's violent response was only made in self-defense?
  42. If my partner physically abuses me and I reciprocate -- even if I admit my reciprocation was not in self-defence but out of anger -- is it unlikely I will be arrested?
  43. If I am divorced and my former partner earns more than I do, is it more likely that I will be awarded spousal support, even if I am employed and self-supporting, than if the positions were reversed?
  44. If I am divorced, is the default assumption in Family Court that I will be given primary custody of my children?  Will this still be the case even if my former partner and I shared bread-winning and childcare duties roughly equally during the marriage?
  45. If I am divorced and my former partner sues for child custody, are they unlikely to be as successful as I would be were our positions reversed?  Will the burden be on them to prove that I am an unfit parent, rather than that they are more fit than I am, before this likelihood tips in their favor?
  46. If I am divorced and have primary custody of our children, am I more likely to be awarded child support from my former partner than they would be if our positions are reversed?
  47. If I am divorced and have primary custody of our children, and my former partner does not abide by the tems of the custody.child support order, will they be more likely to face legal consequences, such as a prison sentence, than I would be if our positions were reversed?  Will this happen even if the reason for not abiding my the order is that their financial situation has changed such that complying is literally impossible?  Will they face these consequences even if I am not in compliance with the order either, or have been hindering or outright preventing access to their children?
  48. If I am divorced and have primary custody of our children, is my right to distance myself from my former partner likely to take precedence over my children's right to have constant access to their other parent, and my former partner's right to have constant access to their children?
  49. If I am divorced and do not have primary custody of our children, am I far less likely to be ordered to pay child support than my former partner would were our situations reversed?  If I failed to comply with that order, am I unlikely to face any serious legal difficulties because of my defiance of the order?
  50. If I abuse the legal system during my divorce (for instance, by obtaining a fraudulent restraining order based on a bogus domestic violence claim, misrepresenting my financial status, hiding assets, or otherwise perjuring myself) am I unlikely to face any punishment for these crimes than my former partner would be were our positions reversed?
  51. If I abuse the legal system during my divorce, am I still likely to benefit from that abuse even after my self-serving manipulation of the legal system has been discovered by the court?  Moreover, will "the good of the children" be used as a reason to not penalize me for my illegal and deceitful actions?
  52. If my former partner abuses the legal system during my divorce in the manner described in Point 45, are they more likely to be criminally charged or monetarily penalized by the courts because of it.
  53. Are any accusations of rape I make against someone more likely to be believed, even if there exists no kind of evidence to support my accusation at all?
  54. Will any accusation of rape I make against a member of the opposite gender ruin their live and reputation, damage their job prospects, and possibly result in their serving time in jail, even if they are later exonerated?  And am I unlikely to face punishment for falsely making an accusation, even if they are later exonerated?
  55. If I have consensual sex with my partner, and we are both underage, if a statutory rape charge is filed am I the one who won't ever be charged?  Will this be the case even if I was the one to pressure my underage partner into engaging in sex and they objected?
  56. If I am raped by a member of the opposite gender, and I am below the age of consent, are people unlikely to say that no crime has been committed because, as a member of my gender, I wanted to have sex and obviously took advantage of the opportunity?
  57. If I am raped by a member of the opposite gender, are otherwise knowledgeable members of the criminal justice system unlikely to consider my body's involuntary reactions and automatic responses to sexual stimuli "proof" that I really gave consent to have sex?
  58. If I am a victim of a statutory rape committed by a member of the opposite gender, and the rape results in pregnancy, will I have a choice as to what my parental rights regarding that child will be?
  59. If I am a victim of a statutory rape committed by a member of the opposite gender, and the rape results in pregnancy, will I not be held financially responsible for that child if I was raped by an adult?
  60. Irregardless of my parents' culture or religion, or any small beneficial side-effects, am I protected by law from having my genitals mutilated until I am an adult and can request such surgical procedures myself?
  61. Irregardless of my parents' culture or religion, or any small beneficial side-effects, if my genitals have been mutilated am I considered the victim of a heinous crime?
  62. Can I openly state a sexual preference for members of the opposite gender who have had their genitals mutilated and not immediately be called out as a sexist, a sadist, or both by the rest of society?
  63. Can I request a sexual partner of the opposite gender whose genitals have not been mutilated go through the mutilation procedure for me, without that partner or greater society considering me to be a sexist, a sadist, or both?
  64. Can I cite my own sexual preference for members of the opposite gender whose genitals have been mutilated as the sole reason for requesting the same be done to my newbord child without being called out as a sexist, a sadist, or both by the rest of society?
  65. Will my child's doctor comply with mutilating my child's genitals without arguing with me or reporting me to the police?
  66. Will my health insurance pay for the mutilation of my child's genitals without arguing with me or reporting me to the police?
  67. Would it be career suicide for a doctor or political to recomment mutilating my genitals to reduce the chance of catching an STD or having other medical problems?
  68. Is there little no to legal debate as to whether the mutilation of my gender's genitals is bad?
  69. Am I not required to register with the Selective Services, and thus am not subject to a military draft?
  70. In the case of a "full war," I would not be considered a coward or somehow traitorous if I were to refuse to risk my life on my country's behalf.
  71. If I commit a crime, can I expect to receive a lighter sentence for that crime than a person of the opposite gender would receive for committing the same crime?
  72. If I voluntarily choose to join the military, it will I most likely never be called upon to act in a combat capacity except under very unusual circumstances, even if I am in a combat zone?
  73. Are people more likely to blame society for my own personal failings?
  74. If I act eccentrically and am even moderately good looking, will my actions  be seen as "cute" or "endearing" rather than simply weird and off-putting?  In fact, will everything I do or say be seen as such?
  75. Is it generally accepted that members of my gender are disadvantaged and do not enjoy any sort of social privilege at all, regardless of how often I have answered "yes" to the questions on this list?


The point of this list is not to play a game of "who has the most privilege", but to demonstrate that, in different ways and in different manners, both men and women enjoy situations where they have the advantage, and suffer situations where they have the disadvantage.  This is not a race to see who the biggest victim is.


Even if some group is objectively given unfair advantages, it does not in any way, shape, or form follow that all members of that group are advantaged, let alone privileged.  It does not even follow that most members are.  And even if someone is privileged, it absolutely does not follow that his arguments are invalid.  This is the typical reason why privilege is dragged into the discussion:  a silencing tactic.  "You are privileged, ergo you do not know what you are talking about."


In addition, I note the absurd attitude that shines through in many of the "privilege blaming" groups:  if you are a male, or worse, a white male, or even worse a heterosexual white male, or even further worse, a Christian heterosexual white male, you're an inferior being who isn't worth listening to or considering seriously because you're worthless.


If, on the other hand, you qualify for a victim card (by being black, gay, a woman, and so on), you're one of the enlightened elite.


Individuals take advantage of their own privilege.  It's a fact.  Men take advantage of male privilege, even when they actively say they don't try to.  They can't help it.  Likewise, women take advantage of female privilege.  And both men and women are more when the stakes are very, very high.


And before you get too high on your horse about the privileges of the other gender, you (whether you are a man or a woman) would be advised to consider what your life would be like were the gender privilege you currently enjoy was reversed in these situations.

Friday, November 21, 2014

Hyphenated Americans

"All of us, no matter from what land our parents came, no matter in what way we may severally worship our Creator, must stand shoulder to shoulder in a united America for the elimination of race and religious prejudice. We must stand for a reign of equal justice to both big and small."  -- Theodore Roosevelt, 1915
I've had people try to tell me that the reason I wince every time I hear a person describe themselves as a hyphenated American (you know... "Irish-American", "Asian-American, Croatian-Italian-American, and whatever...) is because I am a racist.


My usual reaction is immediately stifling the urge to beat them senseless.


I am not a racist.  Anyone who has seen pictures of my family knows that I'm not a racist.


In point of fact, I tend to not even notice the ethnic background or even the skin color of a person as anything other than trivial data about the individual in question unless that person shoves it into my face.  It just doesn't matter to me what color a person is.


No, the reason I wince is because identifying oneself as a hyphenated American is... well... so exclusionary. Its also vaguely un-American.


Has anyone else noticed the difference in the way in which people are referred? Its become custom to refer to people as African-American, Latino-American, Asian-American, and Native-American rather than referring to them by their skin color, and this is all a good thing.  The less we notice skin color, the less skin color matters.  But then you get to the "white people". Why are they referred to by skin color, when everyone else gets to hyphenate themselves?


And as a short digression, why are they referred to as white? I've never met a white person. I've met some pale tan people, and some pasty peach people, and some light pink people, but never a white person. Wait... small correction. I met a woman in 1996 who was an albino, and I will go on record as saying that she was as close to white as I've seen... but even she had a slight grayish tinge to her skin.


But anyway, why are Caucasians referred to by their skin color?  Is it because they are perceived as the norm against which all other groups are compared?  I hesitate to even suggest it for fear of the return of accusations of racism, but is "white" the skin color in this country that is considered "normal?"


Besides, what in the world could be called a "Normal American" given the absolute truth of our country's diversity?


Let me use myself as a for instance: I've got ancestral cultures I could hyphenate myself with, were I allowed. My grandparents and great grandparents and great-greats came from England and Scotland and Ireland and France and Norway and Germany and Morocco and Portugal and Malta and Lebanon and the Sudan and Russia and Mali.


Yes, Mali and the Sudan.  I've got close ancestors from Sub-Saharan Africa, folks.  Not so white as I appear.  Heh heh heh heh...


So should I call myself an Anglo-American, Scottish-American, Irish-American, Franco-American, Norwegian-American, German-American, Moroccan-American, Portuguese-American, Maltese-American, Lebanese-American, Sudanese-American, Russian-American, or Malian-American?


And how does the fact that some of my Scots ancestors stopped in Ireland and lived there for five generations before coming to America affect things?


Or the fact that some of my French ancestors moved to England and lived there for close to a hundred years before returning to France?


For that matter, some of my English ancestors settled in the Bahamas and lived for three generations before moving on to South Carolina.


Am I an Anglo-Bahamanian-Franco-English, Scotto-Irish-Irish-Norwegian-German-Moroccan-Portuguese-Sudanese, Russio-Malian-American?


I mean, come on... where do I cut this sillyness out?


Besides, "country of origin" is only accurate if you put a time limit on it.


Human beings have been migrating for several million years now, and every time a tribe moves into a new area, they either merge with the folks already there, kill everyone whose already there, or drive out everyone whose already there. This sort of continual movement has blended racial and ethnic characteristics in all of us.


(Maybe I should call myself a Celtic American, since the majority of my ancestry lies in countries that were settled by Celtic people.)


I do not hyphenate myself because I do not identify culturally with any of those places. I was born and raised here, in this country, and except for two years in Germany and a year in Japan with the Army, I've never spent any significant time anywhere else.  My cultural identity is with the United States.


Of course, I'm betting you can start interviewing people who call themselves African-Americans and spend all day before you find one whose actually spent a great deal of time in Africa. And I'm not talking about a one week vacation, either. I'm talking about spending years, living as an African.


This brings up another issue:  Africa is not one big monolithic cultural block.  Rather, there are thousands if not hundreds of thousands of different cultures on that continent, and I think to claim the entire thing as your "cultural heritage" is being greedy. After all, I don't get to claim all of Europe, why should they get to claim all of Africa? This greediness gets even worse when you bring "Asian-Americans" into the picture. The "Asian-Americans" get to claim half of the Earth's land mass as their own, despite the fact that when people say "Asian-American" they mean "Oriental".


Except you can't say "Oriental" anymore, because its racist.


Of course, even saying "Oriental" is inaccurate.  Want to get your ass kicked in Korea?  Call a Korean man Japanese.  Its as sure to start a fight as calling an Irishman English.


What's my point?


That Korea isn't Japan, and that Japan isn't Viet Nam, and that Viet Nam isn't India, and that India isn't Burma, and so on.  If you insist on hyphenating yourself, get specific.


Here's something else: why are no one but American Indians allowed to call themselves "native" to the North American continent?  I was born on this continent, and have lived the greater majority of my life on it.  My ancestors have lived on this continent for thirteen generations, and my children and grandchildren will likely be born here for hundreds of generations past me.  Does that not make us natives of this continent?  Its not like American Indians are indigenous to North America either... their ancestors came from somewhere else just like mine did.  Maybe they qualify as aboriginal to North American, but not indigenous, and therefore not native.


Speaking of aboriginals... a friend of mine named Corey (who, coincidentally, happens to be black) and I were once at the Federal Courthouse in Orlando when a man distributing leaflets cornered us. The leaflet distributor pressed the sheet of paper into my friend's hand and began talking to him about the issue thereto, which had something to do with "African American solidarity" or something.  Corey, my friend, looked at the leaflet, laughed quietly, then gave it to me too look at. The distributor got incensed at this, loudly proclaiming that the information it held was intended for "African-Americans Only!!!!" (emphasis added for accuracy).


Corey laughed again and handed the leaflet back, saying 'In that case, take it back... my ancestors are from Australia...".


There is, of course, a really serious downside to all this hyphenation.


When we hyphenate ourselves, we are basically saying that we no longer are a part of the Great American Melting Pot.  Rather, we are a part of a single tribe, and we hold true to the traditions, customs, and language of that tribe above even the homeland which birthed us.  This exclusivity has nearly destroyed the feeling of community once felt in the United States, because insisting on being referred to as a hyphenated American amounts to declaring that you aren't an American. A hyphenated American is saying "Your America is not my America, because my America is filled with people like me."


"We the People..." is coming to mean smaller and smaller groups in this country. Consider the rise of ethnically based lobbying groups and political action committees lately.  The Republican Party here in Florida does nothing without the approval of the Cuban-American voters. The Democratic Party of New York does nothing to offend the Jewish voters.  In Arizona, its the Mexican-Americans.  In Illinois, its the Polish-Americans. When is this ethnic-based separatism going to end?


Its a dangerous road we walk on. When you ground your personal identity with a single group, you tend to do what you have to in order to feel good about your own particular group. In modern human beings, this tends to become racist simplifications. Blacks are all ignorant. Irish are all drunks. Muslims are all terrorists. Jews are all greedy. Italians are all gangsters. Hispanics are all illegal immigrants. And whites are all racist. When we segregate ourselves into small clannish groups, we perpetuate these stereotypes willingly even when we know better.


E Pluribus Unum, remember? We're supposed to be one out of many. The way we're going, we're never going to get there.


As for me, I fall back on the words of Daniel Webster, who said: "I was born an American, I have lived as an American, and I shall die an American."


A hyphen doesn't even enter into it.